![]() |
| With glasses and a punch |
Swickard: To deal with today's boy behavior
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, January 24, 2016
© 2016 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. I was born a small boy. Yes, small.
And yes a boy. Both were a problem in public school. The first because it
attracted larger boys who exercised boy behavior at my expense and the second
because I accepted that is how boys are supposed to act. And so I had to adapt
to being smaller than other boys.
Sometimes I even admired how larger
boys pushed me around since I thought at some point I would grow to be as big
as my father. I didn't get a growth spurt until ninth grade. Previously I was
one of the smallest in each class.
But I have always been a boy and
therefore I had plenty of boy behavior hardwired into my very being. If I was
punched my automatic response was to hit back. No, I didn't go tattle to adults;
I tried to land a blow on the tip of the offender's nose where it would start a
nose-bleed.
Public schools tried to extinguish
all boy behavior when I was in public school since it was loud, chaotic and irritating
to adults. We boys were treated as if we were dysfunctional girls. We were
treated as if we had not thought of what would be acceptable behavior.
"What were you thinking?" was a
frequent question. Truth: wasn't thinking, just reacting as a boy.
Public schools then and now try to make
all children act like girls. Pay attention, don't take cuts in line and don't
ever punch another boy. The expected behavior of schools is modeled after girls
who act like girls.
In the 1980s when my daughter was in
third grade she was pushed around by a boy. I taught her something my Uncle
Ralph taught me when I was young. It is a punch called the Hook. I didn't talk
to the school about the boy behavior that is always at public schools, I gave
her a way to deal with it. We practiced it.
Young kids throw straight lefts and
rights which are easily blocked. The hook comes out of left field and knocks
the offender down. Her mother and the school weren't pleased with her knocking the
boy down but he never pushed her again. Nor did any boy at that school. After
her lecture was over, she came and high fived me.
That is what Uncle Ralph's lesson
did for me. I was much smaller but packed a punch. My father was in the Air
Force and we moved eight times in my public school time. Each new school had a
bully or a couple bullies that picked on new smaller kids. But not me more than
once.
My mother and the schools were
exasperated with me hitting back. But I was usually left alone afterwards. And
I learned to rely upon my own self instead of thinking I had to be protected by
adults. They were never there when the flan hit the fan.
It is in the public dialog that
bullying in public schools is rampant and out of control. There are many new
procedures. The newest ones command the kids to not fight back when attacked.
Rather, to take their assault and make a report to an adult. The schools are
ramping up anti-bullying administrators, hiring more and more adults to take
over the fight rather than teach children to be their own advocate. That is
pure crap!
No I'm not saying the way to end all
bullying is protective headgear and eight ounce gloves. But one thing is for
sure. Throughout our children's lives they will be pushed around. Thinking that
the only way to deal with abuse is to get a government higher authority to
attend to it is lunacy.
Yes, the government must deal with
cases of physical abuse beyond a certain level. And often a restraining order
only works when the person also has a pistol and is willing to use it. We need
to teach our children to take responsibility for themselves as much as
possible.
Often it is just boy behavior anyway
and should not trigger having a SWAT team parachute into the school. Let boys
be boys and teach everyone how to cope.
Email: drswickard@comcast.net
Swickard: The lost world of human capital
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, January 17, 2016
© 2016 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. "Achieving
the highest possible return on human capital must be every manager's goal." Brian Tracy People in business know the value of human capital, but do we citizens? Brian Tracy writes about the value of good employees. I was thinking about the human capital of our citizens, as a whole, in our country. Some of that valuable human capital is being lost. And we are not attending to our losses.
We spend lots of money educating all
children. Billions of dollars are being used in public education and colleges.
We get doctors, lawyers and engineers along with people in the trades who keep
our country functioning. We, as a country, are only as good as all of our
citizens.
However, a third of all children
drop out of a free education and often end up in jail. America loses when people
who could have invented something useful or who would have raised children well
are put in prison for non-violent crimes. America needs those Americans, but our
leaders have a political need to ruin lives.
The New Mexico Legislature leaders
are talking for this session about getting tougher on crime. As if this country
has not being doing that for decades. That sounds nice in political speeches but
our country is either a Police State right now or very close to it.
I do realize that violent crimes
must be dealt with harshly. No, I am talking about non-violent crimes that have
filled our prisons to capacity and more. We have allowed police units to become
a military of their own.
Everywhere I go I am under the
watchful eye and firearm of the police. Every action I take is monitored by a
government agency. Not just me, every American. Yes, the NSA said they were
going to stop spying on Americans. They are such liars.
Here's the problem: progressives
from both parties over the last one hundred years have used any excuse to make
government bigger and bigger. The War on Drugs
for the last seventy years has just been an excuse to turn our country into a de facto Police State. Sadly, drugs are
just as plentiful today as when they started.
America's incarceration rates are
far beyond any other free country and now the New Mexico Legislature wants to
toughen up the laws, which means incarcerate more New Mexicans. These are just
numbers to the politicians and leaders. But they are flesh and blood humans.
And we are losing their potentials. When
we incarcerate them then all of their talents are lost and often lost forever. Some
convicts do come out of prison and restart their lives. And that is the lesson.
We really lose when we keep people incarcerated their entire lives.
In the last year I have gotten to
know someone who five years ago was in prison. I think his violations were drug
related. When he got out all he could get was a janitor's job. But amazingly he
was the best janitor that company had ever seen. He is naturally clever without
any college.
Over a couple of years he first became
assistant manager and then a store manager. I am being vague because I do not
have permission to identify this person. I have owned several businesses and
run others. This person's store reflects his great managerial skills. So do his
employees. Even when he is not in his store I see him in every one of his
employees.
He is changing lives by leadership. Years
ago he was in prison and only by the fortune of a company taking a chance on
him do we see the potential of his human capital. How much value are we losing
when we send so many to prison?
Becoming a Police State benefits politicians
and unions by having many more people employed in police departments, courts
and prisons. It is a vast ever-growing industrial complex that knows no bounds.
New Mexico is getting tougher on crime for more political benefits. And we all
lose the human capital from our society.
America thought their way to the
moon. Can we readjust our legal system so as to not lose all of this human
capital? Perhaps.
Email: drswickard@comcast.net
Swickard: The lost world of human capital
Swickard: The wealth effect in politics
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, January 10, 2016
© 2016 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. It's no secret money and power flows
to and from politics. Lots of it. This has been the modus operandi of our political system for much of our country's
history. Countering those politicians and money waving influencers are supposed
to be the mainstream media.
They're supposed to watch for bad
behavior in politicians and take the side of the citizens. But now they are
taking sides for themselves in the political fights. They are vicious against
the politicians they oppose while absent from the watchdog role with the
politicians they support.
In the last twenty years the
Internet has blossomed in a watchdog role despite taking no vows to be
accurate. With all of these eyes watching politicians you would think scummy
behavior by elected officials would be as dead as television rabbit ears.
However, scummy behavior in
politicians seems more rampant than ever. With the next session of the New
Mexico Legislature set to start shortly there are many initiatives looking to
reign in the influence of money in politics. Transparency watchdogs are pushing
for tougher reporting of campaign donations.
What it shows is that few people really
understand the scummy side of politics. Paper shufflers and those who look at
the paperwork only get a tiny look at scummy behavior. Filed paperwork only
shows mistakes made in reporting but not the real intent.
The real players when major money is
given and taken do not intend for it to be seen. When a willing bribe giver and
a willing bribe takers exchange there is not any paperwork filed. If both
parties are happy no one will talk about it. The same is true for those politicians
who sell out for sexual rewards or jobs for relatives.
To see the real effect of money on
politics you must look at a measured effect of the money. Not the decisions
elected officials make because there are always explanations. If someone is on
the take, their net worth goes up. But the watchdogs are not looking at net
wealth increases.
If watchdogs don't look at the
wealth effect, they will not see it. What needs to be done by the investigative
reporters is very mundane and labor intensive: chart every year of service as
to the net worth of the person serving. Start with the year before elected and
keep a running tab on how their wealth changes.
There are ways to hide wealth with
spouses and children and other relatives. But wealth sticks out in our society
because to have wealth is to use it. Just piling up numbers in an account
doesn't do anyone any good. To have money is to spend money.
So when looking at a public servant
on the take there will always be evidence of unbridled increase in wealth. This
is especially so when you compare them to colleagues. Some people in politics
will have a similar wealth before, during and after their years in service.
Others hit the jackpot and pile up wealth.
Of course there will always be
explanations such as: I started a new way of investing. It is returning a
thousand percent per month... Can we see your market report? Ah no.
It is important to treat each wealth
inquiry fairly and not with partisan zeal so that some slip through and others
are caught. For this to be useful we must catch everyone who spins up their
wealth briskly while in office.
Questions of fantastic increases in
wealth are not proof of taking bribes, but it certainly opens the door to
looking very carefully. But if this inquiry is automatic to all who are elected
it will discourage bribes because when caught politicians turn on the bribe
givers. There is no one thing to clean up politics but this will help.
Most importantly, it is unfair to
the honest servants of the people to look at them like they are a chicken
killing dog. The effect of the time served on honest politicians shows they give
citizens a great gift of their time and effort while not taking any advantage
of their position.
We owe them this inquiry to catch
scummy politicians. We are left with honest and faithful servants.
Email: drswickard@comcast.net
Swickard: The wealth effect in politics
Swickard: The real statehood day in New Mexico
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Wednesday, January 6, 2016
| Bottom right, William Gallacher |
© 2016 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. Today I am thinking of New Mexico
Statehood Day, January 6th, 1912. Also I'm thinking of William Gallacher, the
last surviving member from the New Mexico State University Class of 1908. He
died at age ninety-eight a few years ago. He was living in New Mexico on
statehood day so I asked him about it.
From living in White Oaks, N.M.
before the turn of the twentieth century and before the railroads came; he
lived to see the landing of the space shuttle sixty miles from his ranch. He
was thirty-five miles away from the first atomic explosion at Trinity Site,
July 16, 1945.
He was also one of the few who could
look up in the sky and say, "Halley’s Comet, what do you know, there it is
again."
I drove out to his ranch in 1978 to
ask him about the day New Mexico became a state. January 6, 1912 was the day
that President Taft signed the official paperwork.
Since Bill was four years out of
college by then he would be a perfect person to ask. I pictured writing a story
about people firing guns in the air, firecrackers going off, dogs barking,
people toasting statehood at the local bar and speeches being made about,
"Our date with destiny and our place in the sun."
New Mexico spent sixty years trying
to become a state with one thing or another stalling our chances. In 1912 we made
it. Gallacher’s neighbor, William McDonald was New Mexico’s first elected
governor, and owner of the famous Bar W ranch north of Carrizozo.
Bill greeted me warmly and we sat
over coffee at the kitchen table. He was the kind of person to always look
right at you when he spoke. You knew right away what he thought. We started off
by discussing the happenings of the day. Bill was like that, more interested in
today than yesterday.
After a while we had run through all
of the available topics so I told him my perception that there must have been a
big celebration in Lincoln County since the first elected governor was a local
rancher.
He thought a moment and then leaned
closer, as a school master would a student who was a slow learner,
"Celebrations?" He remembered back all of those years and did not
smile.
"On the day we became a state I
got up about an hour before dawn, had a little breakfast and at first light
went out to tend to sick animals, kill coyotes and do all of the chores that
used up an entire day. About an hour after sunset I came back in and had a
little supper then went to bed.
"I was cold, tired and hungry.
I would not have gone into town for any celebration. We hardly noticed
statehood the first few years. Most of us were too busy just trying to stay
alive, to feed ourselves and to carve out a place that would become our home to
notice any politicians, not even a fine cattleman like McDonald.
"Every day I got up early and
worked late. I had no other energy and did not come in off of the range
sometimes for months at a time."
He noticed my lack of comprehension
so continued, "Politicians and celebrations were a luxury most of us then
could not afford. For thirty years on this land I worked with all of my energy.
It was not a forty hours a week job, it was dawn to dark seven days a week or
we would not have made it. Only after the ranch was on solid footing did I
notice the government. I served on the Lincoln County Commission and the school
board."
I was thankful that Bill brought me
back to reality before I wrote something silly about the celebrations the
citizens all had when New Mexico
became a state. It was a hard time back then, more so than most of us can even
realize. And January 6, 1912
was, for most of the citizens of New
Mexico , just one more working day.
The way to celebrate the anniversary
correctly is by going to work early and working late.
Swickard: The real statehood day in New Mexico
Swickard: Half of all Americans are below average
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, January 3, 2016
![]() |
| Surprise for my high school teachers |
© 2016 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. "For
the first time ever, overweight people outnumber average people in America.
Doesn't that make overweight the average then?" Jay Leno
I salute the wisdom of Jay Leno. My
high school nickname was "Slim" since I swam competitively in high
school. Today when someone says, "Hey Slim," I know they are just
trying to get a rise out of me. But I'm now average.
Since the Clemson - Alabama game is
a couple days away I was thinking of William "The Fridge" Perry who in
1981 played on the National Championship Clemson team and then on the Super
Bowl Chicago Bears team. Coach Ryan gave him the nickname of "Biscuit."
The coach said, "The Fridge is only one biscuit away from 350
pounds."
And perhaps we could say I am just
one bowl of green chile and beef away from having to buy new clothes. Hence
this week is the start of the 2016 annual diet week where I do gerbil like
activity until I get distracted from all of that exercise. However, this year I
have a Fitbit activity tracking band that counts my steps so perhaps I will
turn over a new leaf. Perhaps indeed.
Americans try to understand average.
I can safely mention this since we just got by the Thanksgiving Christmas and
New Year's juggernaut of extra calories. After a successful holiday season, I
resemble the average American.
We swim in a sea of statistics with
very few people understanding what they suggest. When I say that half of all
Americans are below average the average American wants to do something about
it. We can't have all of those Americans being below average, or can we?
This notion has been humorously
dealt with by Garrison Keillor's A Prairie
Home Companion where in the segment News
from Lake Wobegon he says, "... (Lake Wobegon) where all the women are
strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above
average."
In 1987, John Cannell, a Virginia
physician, noticed at that time every state claimed their students were above
average. Further, the student scores were found to be uniformly above average
in all states. This syndrome was then labeled the “Lake Wobegon Effect.”
In a recent poll 95% of all drivers
rated themselves above average drivers. Go figure. I admit it sounds bad to be
below average if we care about whatever we are being judged upon. In public
school I was a statistical average student consistently getting the grade of C.
Teachers in exasperation would say, "You could get a B or an A if you
tried."
They didn't understand my philosophy:
if you turn homework in, they will expect it every time. So the non-existent
dog ate my homework. And I cultivated a persona of not being academically
inclined. Truth be known I was just not tuned to their radio station as the
saying goes.
Should we rate my teachers down
because I was not interested in high school except for the things that I found
interesting? In a conversation about my lack of achievement since I had just
over a two point zero grade point average my mother mentioned to the counselor
that I owned a couple thousand books.
Yep, I read all of the time when I
wasn't doing sports. But I didn't find what they wanted me to know interesting.
As far as students going to go to college I was very much below average. But
they just did not understand me since I achieved a Ph.D. when I decided that it
was what I wanted.
The great failing of our public schools
is that they are focused on the adults, not the kids. Some kids are more
compliant than others. All of the measures of public schools are actually only measuring
how compliant the kids are in today's schools. Most are just not compliant.
Me, I would purposely get every
answer wrong on the accountability tests if I was forced to take it. I know
myself and how I dealt with public school fifty years ago. And I would be
labeled below average. So? What the accountability would measure with me is my
engagement with their agenda. I am not.
Swickard: Half of all Americans are below average
Swickard: Each year has a lesson to teach
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, December 27, 2015
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. In a small unscientific study
looking only at myself I find that the years go by quickly. They are packed
with victories and losses. If we have a loss, at least we should get the
lesson. Getting lemons doesn't help unless you have sugar and water for
lemonade.
Let's look at 2015 as we think about
2016. We must remember the mistakes that were made this year so we don't repeat
them. We also need to remember our victories so we have some chance to repeat
them.
George Santayana in 1906 wrote,
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." Our
society doesn't seem to learn. Let's make 2016 the year we learn from a
previous year's mistakes.
If there was an organization to
remember society's wins and losses each year they would say you must
acknowledge both the wins and losses. Losses are difficult because people gloss
over them while fixating on wins.
The biggest loss in the last few
years is the loss of the truth. Truth has become the new hate speech. George
Orwell wrote, "During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes
a revolutionary act."
Many people are afraid of the truth
because an expedient political power play has emerged in our society. It is to
label as racist or worse anyone who opposes the wishes of the political parties.
2015 was a name-calling year with most of the name-calling being done for
political gain.
A friend runs a political blog and
has a hard time with the inclination of some posters to name-call and act ugly.
I am glad he is fighting that fight because we can never have truth in our
society if the name-calling brigands are allowed to take over public dialogs.
The year 2015 will be remembered as
the year everything offended someone. David Bednar wrote, "To be offended
is a choice we make; it is not a condition inflicted or imposed upon us by
someone or something else."
This year I found I could
concurrently offend both Republicans and Democrats. I got hate emails from both
the same week. I have written a weekly column for more than thirty years so I am
used to offending people. It happens. But this year it seemed that there was a virulent
practiced response to opposing ideas and that was name-calling and ignoring the
truth.
One person was very offended when I
wrote about something that happened in the 2015 New Mexico Legislature. The
problem for me was that I did not witness this situation myself. But I found
four people who confirmed to me what happened along with two others in law
enforcement who witnessed it. I would not retract my column.
This last year the two major
political parties were nationally very similar. The only thing they disagree on
was which person should be elected, not the will of the people and how Congress
should protect the Constitution.
The emphasis of 2015 for the
national leaders of both parties was to make government bigger. This has been
covered extensively by the national press that can be identified by their
political editorial leanings. Both the liberal press and the less liberal press
have their agendas. If it wasn't for the Internet they would succeed.
Many years ago Bob Hope quipped,
"No one party can fool all of the people all of the time; that's why we
have two parties." A friend said to one politician, "Please act as if
you actually talk to citizens and not just consultants and fixers." That
didn't go over well.
Comedian George Burns was asked,
"How's your wife?" He answered, "Compared to what?" That is
what we have to realize each year. When we do a year in review in some ways we
are often comparing to other years.
Can we learn from 2015? Yes, but we must
want to learn. We may have to change some of our elected politicians if we want
real change. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1789, "Whenever people are well
informed they can be trusted with their own government."
We have many well-informed citizens
but everyone loses when truth is politically inconvenient and so is absent from
our society.
Swickard: Each year has a lesson to teach
Swickard: When it is too early for formal public schooling
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, December 13, 2015
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. Question: when is the best age to
start children in public schools? This is like the question: why not teach algebra
to five-year olds? Answer: our brains must develop before we can do formal
logic. The age to start formal public school education is not until the age of six.
However, a big push in our society
by well-meaning people and power-hungry politicians is that earlier contact
with school makes a better scholar. They say that while ignoring the research.
They have many reasons not involving the welfare of the children when they want
to start children younger.
However, others people, myself
included, feel that certain brain development phases must occur for children to
thrive in a formal education setting. Research which I will point to suggests you
can injure young children by putting them in formal academic settings too soon.
We should look at the research but
the way many professional educators have been operating of late is to ignore
all research that doesn't support what they want. They say, "Forget the
research we want to have a bigger empire and employ more people."
When I was young most students began
their formal education at the age of six. The generation that sent men to the
moon and returned them safely started their schooling at this age. It works.
The children were in family or church daycare until it was time to start
school.
Then there came kindergarten. In the
1960s there was the adoption of public school kindergarten for many students.
In New Mexico it was the middle of the 1970s when the public schools uniformly started
offering kindergarten. But that kindergarten was vastly different than what we
see now.
Back then it was only for half of
the day and focused on play activities. Children sang songs and played games
and took naps and went home saying, "I love school." Then
well-meaning people said, "Why don't we keep them all day." It made
sense since parents would not have to accommodate the other half of the day.
The beauty for the politicians was it
allowed public schools to hire twice as many kindergarten teachers. And for a
while that was how schools went. But then administrators started talking about changing
kindergarten into a formal academic activity.
They justified changing kindergarten
to formal education for five year olds so when these young students are in
fourth grade they will do better making the school seem more successful. Kindergarten
now doesn't look like it did. The play and informal curriculum is gone and the
five year olds are just trying to learn the six year old stuff a year early.
How is that working? Terrible but no one is paying attention.
Research at Stanford University suggests
the move to get children into academic classrooms sooner comes with liabilities.
There is an interesting study that even mainstream news organizations are
noticing. It is: The Gift of Time? SchoolStarting Age and Mental Health.
This research from Stanford
University looks at when students start and if starting a year later would be
better. There are countries that start their children later in school. What is
the outcome?
The later starting children do
better on the fourth and eighth grade tests and seem to not have as many mental
health issues. But the research doesn't fit the political needs of our
education leaders. The vast industrial public education complex needs the young
children in the system.
And I am fine with that if these
politicians will just read the research and see that they can make the first
year a year of curiosity, play and social involvement but they cannot teach
formal education to the majority of the five year olds.
Further, we must see our young
children by their number of day alive and not birth year. I was born seven days
before the cutoff so I was the youngest and smallest boy in most of my classes.
Some of my competing classmates were fifteen percent older than me that first
year.
The Stanford study, which can be
downloaded for five dollars talks about all of these issues. I do wish some of
our leaders would look at this great research.
Swickard: When it is too early for formal public schooling
Swickard: Free college or free students from college?
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, December 6, 2015
![]() |
| Grandfather E V McKim Sr's practical education |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. One of the talking points for
politicians is free college for students. They reason that preschool to high
school graduation in public education is free, why not college? It is not free,
someone else pays.
Perhaps we should debate the aim of our
education system. Thomas Jefferson wrote that education had two aims, "The
laboring and the learned. Few students had the ability to be (academically) learned
but our country always needs educated labor."
In today's world our public schools push
all students to attend college. In 1968 it was not my intention to attend college.
My Grandmother Frieda wanted me to go so I went.
In 1917 she got a Masters Degree
from Western New Mexico University in Silver City. It was then New Mexico State
Teachers' College. She had come to New Mexico in 1908 from upstate New York to
be a teacher in a one room schoolhouse in Three Rivers. Later she taught in
White Oaks.
Of her children only my uncle went
to college. He got a degree in Electrical Engineering in 1952 after serving in
the Navy during WWII. I went to New Mexico State University in 1968 reluctantly
since I already was a fine photographer. My father taught at the Air Force
School of Photography. I thought I had all of the education I needed.
But my grandmother saw something in
me that a college education made better. Ultimately I got a Ph.D. in
Educational Administration with a focus on distance education. But I could have
just been a photographer and writer. Life is a funny old dog when it comes to
what we set out to do and what happens.
America was built by artisans and
laborers. Two of my great-grandparents came to America to work on the
railroads, one from Sweden and the other from Ireland. My Grandmother Frieda's
husband was a railroad engineer in steam locomotives.
He only went through the fourth
grade but could fix almost anything. Today some are saying that only the
academics really matter. Tell that to someone with an overflowing toilet.
In Junior High I took six semesters
of shop covering tools, wood, metal, electrical, automotive, and home building during
those three years. It was outstanding. I am handy enough to handle most things
and experienced enough to know when things need to be fixed by someone who
really knows what they are doing.
We will always need handy people in
our society. Everything will break, we just do not know when. Instead of
pushing every student to college we should smile on all education, be it
academic or mechanical.
The movement for free college really
is because colleges in the last twenty years have increased the tuition and
fees many times the inflation rate. I went to New Mexico State University
twenty years ago for my Ph.D. The tuition and fees were about six hundred
dollars a semester.
Currently at NMSU it is nearly four
thousand dollars a semester so that either parents must pay the cost or the
students incur lots of debt. The student-loan default rate is terrible. The
solution for some is free college to keep students from going into debt. But
should they be going to college in the first place?
The college graduation rate in New
Mexico is perhaps forty percent with many students just quitting. These
students have student loan debt and no degree. That is one of the things
driving the horrible student loan default rate.
Many of the current graduates are
either under-employed or unemployed. The college degree for many did not make
life better as to supporting themselves. Now one of my favorite classes at
college was a wonderful year of Irish writing from poetry to novels. But what
pays the bills are the things I do which require my Ph.D. No, column writing
does not require a degree, but my statistics and research background helps.
Perhaps the current generation of
college students who have graduated and cannot find a degree-required job should
have explored something more practical to do. Would it be better if they had a professional
trade to support themselves? They could afford college later if they found a desire
to change fields.
Swickard: Free college or free students from college?
Swickard: The flaw in hating flawed leaders
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, November 29, 2015
![]() |
| Pat Garrett - Guts, Gumption and Courage |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. "The
one thing I want to leave my children is an honorable name." Theodore
Roosevelt
Even more modern presidents like
Theodore Roosevelt are legitimately under attack for their flaws. And all
forty-three men who have taken the oath of office for the presidency are
flawed. There are some flawed with graft, some with goofy ideas and some with
being intentionally ignorant in times of crisis.
This is not a black and white issue.
We must view our leaders in a more mature way than these protesters are doing.
There is a more compelling story about the founding leaders clear up to our
leaders today: what did they do for the ages.
That is the yardstick for me: what
did these leaders do that others could not or would not such that we have the
country we have today. Our country has brought freedom to other countries by
example and by fighting wars, not for our own gain, but to insure freedom from
dictators for other people.
As to our founding leaders and the
complaints currently about them: all of the leaders who founded our country
either were slave holders or did not effectively resist the holding of slaves.
That much is true. And we cannot change that flaw in them.
Some people suggest we even change
the name of our national capital because George Washington was a slave holder.
The angels on earth who created liberty for much of the world were flawed
humans. Yet through their actions we have our freedom today.
But in the arena of public opinion there
is an outcry to cleanse our national history of those who were flawed. And it
is every leader we have ever had starting with the first ones during our Revolutionary
War. It is a mistake to not consider all of each man.
Thomas Jefferson is under attack and
unable to defend himself. He wrote for the ages, "We hold these truths to
be self-evident: that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their
Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty,
and the pursuit of happiness."
Yes Jefferson was a flawed man in
that he had slaves. And with Jefferson there are other things. But one of the
problems with revising history is can we do without the good just to punish the
bad?
There were arguably four men who
were essential to the Revolutionary War: George Washington who brilliantly
commanded the weaker American forces into ultimate victory: Samuel Adams who
provided the man-on-the-street leadership in effective citizen resistance; Benjamin
Franklin who got the French to side with our nation or we would not have won
and Thomas Jefferson who provided the words for our new country.
Alas, can we find anyone who is not
flawed? My favorite modern person, Martin Luther King, Jr. was certainly
flawed. Yet he wrote for the ages, "I have a dream that my four little
children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the
color of their skin, but by the content of their character."
In New Mexico we falsely worship a
rascal we call Billy the Kid and ignore a man, yes flawed, who is a hundred
times more interesting historically and as a member of our state: Pat Garrett.
He was flawed in some ways and a legend by his resolve and courage. He had
gumption and guts and ran toward the problem not away.
In no way do I advocate obscuring
the flaws of our leaders. We see that Americans in general have a simplistic
view of our presidents, "George Washington was the father of our country
and a good man." That is a disservice to their sacrifices.
We have had some bad actions by men in
the Oval Office which should be known. But ultimately let's take a look at
their entire effect upon our country.
Email: drswickard@comcast.net
Swickard: The flaw in hating flawed leaders
Swickard: Thanksgiving is an Immigrant holiday
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, November 22, 2015
| Great-grandparents Erik and Johanna and Grandmother Freda |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. "It's
a bit of a sore spot, Thanksgiving in Indian country." Robbie Robertson whose
mother was Mohawk raised on the Six Nations Reservation in Canada
For much of our history immigration
was a benefit for both political parties. Then in 1914 something happened that
changed our view of immigrants: the first year of our federal income tax.
It passed in 1913 and in 1914
politicians had a wave of money to buy votes thanks to the people who worked.
It was and is a tax on productivity therefore those who are productive like it
less than those who get the benefits without working.
Before 1914, immigration was open and
appreciated. It brought workers to our country that had to stand on their own
feet or suffer the consequences. Our transcontinental railroads were built by immigrants.
The immigrants who came to America from
the time of our founding until 1914 were people who could and did stand on
their own feet. They added to our country's resources rather than taking
resources. My relatives came from Germany, Ireland and Sweden not for American
charity but for a chance to live a better life.
My Great-Grandfather Erik Greenberg
came from Sweden in 1867 and worked on the railroad. My grandmother was born in
upstate New York in 1891. In 1908 the family moved to New Mexico and
homesteaded land near Three Rivers. He is buried in Alamogordo.
These days we frame immigration as
our charity to the world where we take care of people from other countries. Americans
support them with our productivity. This is also the debate about people who
come to our country without legal status or stay illegally.
The prime objection is that these
people take our charity without giving us in America anything of value. While
that is painting with a wide brush, it is the argument against allowing illegal
immigration in our country. I think America should always be open to those who
bring us something and follow our laws.
I have a world view from having
lived some years abroad and with the ability to speak several languages. I
appreciate other cultures and especially appreciate the melting-pot aspect of
America where for generations people of other lands came and made America
stronger.
This Thanksgiving I am most thankful
for this wonderful country. I know Americans took by force the lands and ways
of life of the inhabitants already in North America. I cannot do anything about
that other than tell the truth. The Thanksgiving story is revisionist history
since it happened around 1620 and the story of Thanksgiving we know came out
during the Revolutionary and Civil Wars when the image of Thanksgiving was used
to bolster American spirits.
We should go out of our way to
enable the current generations of Native Americans to live their lives as they
wish because we know the truth of their loss. As to people who wish to come to
our land without legal status or stay beyond their legal permit, I must oppose
this for a reason not in public dialog currently.
If in the year of my birth, 1950,
President Truman wanted to spend money on refugees that might be fine. So what
is different today? Truman would have been spending that generation's money.
Contrast that to now when people coming
to our country both legally and illegally with the intention to take our charity
are not taking it from us Americans. Rather, they take it from our children and
grandchildren's wealth. We Americans have already spent our wealth, and now are
spending the wealth of future generations.
Future generations should be allowed
to be charitable if they so desire and not forced into it by us already
spending their wealth before some of them are born. We cannot change what was
done to the native populations centuries ago in what is now our country, but we
can stop abusing the next generations.
That is my prayer for this Thanksgiving.
Swickard: Thanksgiving is an Immigrant holiday



