![]() |
| Education leaders are like King Arthur |
Swickard: The arrogance of educational leadership
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, September 27, 2015
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. Facts are easy. When I was doing
Talk Radio a few years ago I always had a computer in front of me. When there
was a question, the computer provided information quickly. The talking points were
in front of me.
Educational leaders in public
schools say they are teaching thinking but from what I see students spend much
of their time on memorization and how to take tests. Why are we spending so
much time and testing effort essentially teaching test preparation?
Years from now education pundits
will wail, "How could all of those supposedly educated educational leaders
in 2015 be so stupid?" They were stupid because they were overcome with
their arrogance and power.
Example: Picture a superintendent of
a large school district explaining being in charge. The person says, "The Lady
of the Lake, her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite held aloft Excalibur
from the bosom of the water, signifying by divine providence that I was to
carry Excalibur. That is why I am your superintendent."
Well, that may have come from a Monty Python movie, but it is a fine example of the arrogance of leaders. There
is no arguing with the leaders. I know because I have tried, but they have
Excalibur, etc.
A college department that certifies
superintendents and principals was the department where I got my Ph.D. so I am
quite familiar with what these educational leaders are taught. For a while after
my 1998 graduation I was an adjunct faculty in that department. Some current
leaders and teachers were in my classes.
Recently I was exasperated with a
principal who I had in class years ago. The end of the conversation was,
"You are not doing any of the things we taught you to do as an educational
leader nor are you using research to guide you." This person answered,
"But I am legally in charge so I can do what I want."
There are two main contentions of
the current public education management: First, that increased management will always
improve educational outcomes and, the change agent for learning is entirely
teachers. Both are wrong but we, as a society, have put our money and power in
the hands of administrators.
We have an administrator-centric
system where everything is about administrators. Every administrator hired
comes up with more administrative requirements to where teachers I am in
contact with say they no longer teach, they just work making data sheets for
administrators so the administrators can hire more administrators to make more
teacher requests.
But are we improving education? More
importantly, will the improvement be useful when these students are adults. Public
Education is not supposed to be an end in itself for school children; it is the
living of life as an adult that ultimately matters.
The U. S. Department of Health and
Human Services in 2012 had a report that indicated the Federal Program, Head
Start, had many immediate benefits for students but those benefits did not appear
to last into adulthood. The program has gone for five decades so there is a lasting
problem. Childhood leads to adulthood and that is what we should value.
Ultimately what we do for children needs to improve their lives as adults.
The mania is teaching the test so
administrators can game the test and then show on accountability reports that
schools are doing well. But the report of schools doing well will not help students
when they become adults. In fact, this disconnects students from schools.
As a society we need lifelong
learners. What students need to become a lifelong learner is curiosity and support
for their own individual curiosity of all things. However, the schools don't seem
to want curiosity in their classrooms, rather, they want compliant little
robots who do what they are told.
Each year we need to bolster the
curiosity of students, give them literate and numerate tools to satisfy their
curiosity. They will become lifelong learners. Almost all of the real education
in a person's lifetime is self learning.
Teachers are just there to help
students learn to teach themselves. We need to think of the learners and not
the educational leaders who have a cottage industry.
Swickard: Trying to impair the urge to be impaired
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, September 20, 2015
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. At a traffic light the car in front
of me did not move when the light turned green. The driver's head was down, I
suspect looking at text messages. After angry honking finally caused the person
to look up and realize the light changed, the person made it through the light
just as it turned red.
The rest of us had to wait through another
light cycle. I suspect several drivers went back to their cell phones while waiting.
It made me think of the good old days of driving when there were fewer
distractions. However, it is a fact there have always been things that
distracted drivers from their task with the road.
In the 1970s while working for a
television station I went to the scene of a wreck and was talking to a driver
who confessed the wreck was the fault of his cigar. "My cigar slipped out
of my mouth and fell into my lap." he explained. Evidently the fire in his
lap caused him to take his attention off the road. Bam!
Paul and Joseph Galvin were the
developers of car radios around 1930. Once installed, the radio gave the joy of
entertainment but was one more reason for drivers to take their eyes off the
road. It is hard to estimate how many people have died because of car radios.
There have also been beverages. One
morning while leaving a small town I was holding a convenience store cup of fresh
coffee. Concurrent to increasing my speed I was adjusting the radio when I
looked up and a fellow in bib-overalls on a tractor was suddenly in front of
me.
Out of instinct I clutched the paper
coffee cup while applying the brakes thereby pouring very hot coffee all over myself.
The rest of the day I had massive coffee stains but our guardian angels kept us
from colliding.
It seems to me that now our society
has many more distracted drivers. Years ago primarily it was people who drank
and drove that killed thousands upon thousands of people. In just the last ten
years the distractibility index has zoomed. With the advent of cell phones,
texting and video on demand it's a wonder that some young people and some not
so young people are still alive.
Part of the problem is knowing why
vehicles collide. Often it is that the orbits and trajectories of the vehicles
violate the law of not trying to occupy the same space at the same time. At
least the textbook way of driving says running into things is a drag.
There are many theories on how to
stop distracted driving. We see several broad categories of impairment:
alcohol, drugs, sleep deprivation and physical distractions. These impairments
are facts.
Wherever you were last night,
somewhere near you someone was behind the wheel of a car and was impaired. All
good theories on how to combat such activity have a prescriptive component: If
we as a society do this, then that will happen.
Some impaired drivers are caught,
adjudicated and incarcerated. Many more offend day after week after month after
year. We wake to headlines proclaiming a family was slaughtered by an impaired
driver. The media captures the offender's sad face when realizing the effect of
their actions.
The major impairment theory in America
is that threats of a penalty will change behavior. The penalties for impaired
driving have been increasing as politicians stand before the cameras and
proclaim that they have a solution for this scourge: they will pass tougher and
tougher penalties.
Can we as a society be tough? Can we
elevate the penalties for impaired driving to the point that it disappears? For
example, what if we took away a driver’s license for five years on a first
offense? Second time, forever and ever. Would that work?
The problem is that every weekend even
after twenty-five years of DWI heavy enforcement there are people still being
caught. Maybe texting while driving should automatically forfeit the car and serve
time in jail. Are we tough enough to be that tough? Or have we become too soft
to act? We must impair the urge to be impaired while driving.
Swickard: Trying to impair the urge to be impaired
Place names for those honored and not forgotten
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Sunday, September 13, 2015
![]() |
| Professor Marion Hardman |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. One person in college made me a
writer. Previously I had resisted every effort to make me a competent writer
while in public school. At college I was a good photographer, radio announcer
and television director but not much of a writer by choice.
Last week was the dedication of a
lecture hall at New Mexico State University. One of the names on the building
is Marion Hardman who passed away years ago but is alive in my writing. Here is
what happened:
In 1970, as a sophomore at NMSU, my
advisor said, "You'll never graduate if you don’t take English Literature."
I replied, "I’ll take it, but no one can make me like poetry."
Marion Hardman was listed as the
professor. Looking like someone’s grandmother, Professor Hardman stood at the
lectern the first day and through thick glasses softly called the roll. She
seemed frail and out of touch with the modern age.
I looked at my watch impatiently.
Then oddly an hour went by without my notice and she ended the first class. She
began by saying, "Many of you young people are worried about the Vietnam
War which is being fought as we speak."
She had my attention. I was in Air
Force Reserve Officer Training Corps and thought often about the Vietnam War.
She said, "A little more than a hundred years ago Walt Whitman had many of
the same thoughts that you are having today."
Then from memory she quoted some of
the Whitman poetry. Despite my resolve to not learn poetry, I was mesmerized.
When the class ended I was enthused. I have never seen anyone transformed so
completely.
The Professor Hardman that ended the
class could leap tall buildings in a single bound. We hung on her words,
everyone in the class. I wish you could have heard her. She had the ability to
hold a class on each word, to change students with ideas. More importantly to
me she had the ability to bring out talents in students.
Professor Hardman was the first
person to tell me I wrote interesting things, and if I mastered the technical
aspects, I would be a good writer. She said it in a way that was not insulting
and she handed me a book on writing.
That semester I spent every
available minute working on writing. She smiled at the end of the semester and
told me I had really improved. I beamed.
She took each student that way and
helped each in their own way to develop their special talents. I would not be
writing this column if I had not have taken her class. I see her gift to me in
each column I write. That Place Name, Hardman Hall, has special meaning to me.
That is the value of place names.
Every building, road, mountain, etc. has a name. Most people just use the name
to know the place. Example: the name of the tallest mountain in the United
States has been known on maps as Mount McKinley.
Last month by order of the Secretary
of the Interior, Sally Jewell, it is now Denali, which means tall in one of the
seven indigenous languages. Naturally those from Ohio where President William
McKinley was born and is buried prefer the former name.
This opens the debate about place
names: what should be the criteria for changing existing place names. And who
should be in charge of place name changes. New Mexico is full of place names
that reflect many cultures, how should we arbitrate a desire for a different
place name?
For example: if the Native Americans
in the Albuquerque area want the Sandia and Manzano Mountains to reflect what they
were known by for centuries before the Spanish arrived, how do we decide the
name to use?
More so, what about the WisePies
Arena which was known only as The Pit in Albuquerque? Should dollars name it?
It seems we need two things: place names that are measured and fair to all
citizens and we need to make sure that the story of these place name people is well
told.
Changing place names is a can of
worms with the top off now.
Place names for those honored and not forgotten
Swickard: Whom is stealing from whom?
Posted by
News New Mexico
on Friday, September 11, 2015
![]() |
| Danger Will Robinson and us |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. "It
is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker that we
expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interests." Adam Smith,
1776
We need the robot in the television
series Lost in Space to say,
"Danger Will Robinson" when we start playing with what made our
nation strong and wealthy. More so, people in our society do not realize what
keeps each of us alive and therefore they often take actions that are adverse
to our own survival.
Example: no one wants to pay more
for electricity. You never see people holding signs, "Please increase my energy
costs." But people have not really thought this through.
El Paso Electric wants an increase
to cover that they increased their generating ability. Protestors say the
government needs to punish this energy utility.
El Paso Electric along with some
other energy utilities were on the hot seat, wait, it was a cold seat when a
cold wave hit New Mexico in February 2011. What's really bad were the many
people who existed for days without power. Their pipes froze and burst. That
was the start of bad moments.
Fast forward to today when the rate
increase protestors want the power in their homes without paying for the
increased capacity. They accuse the companies providing coal, gas and oil or
taking advantage of them. Yet without power they would die within a week, if
that.
In our modern world we must have
power to transport our food, pump our water, heat or cool our homes and to
travel. Yet the majority of Americans seem to loath the energy producers.
Several people have told me that the proposed El Paso Electric increase is
theft. Really? Whom is stealing from whom?
Most of the bounty in my life has
been provided by strangers for the purpose of each having more for themselves.
I drive a truck made by people who did not know, love and care for me. They were
working because they wanted more. Sure they were professional so I love my
truck but none of us knew each other.
Some say gas prices are high because
of the greedy oil industry. However, the record profits made by oil companies
were exceeded 250 percent by the taxes on those companies. The government made
2.5 times as much as the oil companies with you at the pump paying both the
profit and taxes.
Further, those are just the overt
taxes. Everyone who works to provide fuel, from the researchers and developers
to the drillers and refiners to the transporters and stores, is taxed. You pay
both overt and covert taxes when you buy gasoline.
We know that the high price of gas
is caused entirely by our government not doing the right things to increase
supply. It is stupidity, not greed, that makes energy expensive for Americans.
How much profit should people make?
There is a fuel stop in the middle of nowhere between Phoenix and Los Angeles.
It has a sign, "This gas is expensive. If you don’t need the gas, don’t
buy it." Would those drivers be better off if no gas was sold?
Pushing a car by hand for 50 miles
is at the least daunting. After the first couple of miles of pushing by hand I
think those drivers would gladly pay $100 per gallon.
Everything is regulated by price in
our country. If hamburgers were a quarter, more people would eat them. Gas
costs what people will pay and no more.
It does not matter to me if you do
not want more. Some people live on the land, foregoing electricity, using only
what they need. I would not stop them, but I do not want them to impose their
lifestyle on me. Our country has been and is very prosperous. Let's keep it
that way.
Swickard: Whom is stealing from whom?
The always wait until next year NMSU football program
Posted by
Michael Swickard
on Sunday, August 23, 2015
| Afternoon football at NMSU without many fans early or at all |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. As I have done for most of fifty
years I have New Mexico State University Football Season Tickets. Over the
years there has been a complete lack of Aggie success. NMSU has not gone to a post-season
Bowl since Eisenhower was president.
This has not been due to individual
players or coaches, nor has luck played a part. But there have been
questionable leadership decisions that are keeping the Aggie football program from
being competitive.
Today’s collegiate teams require a
large fan base. NMSU has had no success filling the stadium. Each new coach strides
into Las Cruces a conquering lion and slinks out of town a slaughtered lamb. It
is the administration that chases the fans and dooms the coaches.
The faithful season ticket holders
are a small loyal group. Otherwise the stadium seats are empty except if local
high school teams are playing and then the stadium fills up.
The question each year: will this Aggie
football team finally be successful? Then in October the faithful are forced
to say, “Just wait until next year.”
That said, I have enjoyed moments in
many of the seasons, and have gone decades repeating “wait until next year.” I
have liked many Aggie players, coaches and some college administrators.
The exception was the late 1980s,
when I looked like a dog chewing hot pitch as I left the stadium. During that
stretch the Aggies had four wins and 40 losses.
I believe that the reason for the
lack of success is that for four decades NMSU has been selling losses. Playing
powerhouse teams for money when NMSU has no real chance of winning began as a
temporary tactic to cover a budget shortfall but continues even now. Some teams
try it a few years and give up. Not the Aggies.
On September 5th the Aggies take on
the Florida Gators for money, rather than competition. Then October 10th they
take on Ole Miss again for money not competition. NMSU doesn't have any chance
to win.
NMSU's money-game record is horrible.
And it isn't just the seventy or now eighty or a hundred sold losses that hurt.
The Aggies play powerhouse teams that are much bigger. Aggie players are often hurt
thereby causing the team to lose games later in the season that could have been
won.
The rest of the 2015 NMSU Football
schedule looks playable. Some of the games can be won if the team doesn't get
devastated playing the much bigger teams for money.
I'll be there cheering but I am
angry that the team gets beat up and has two losses outside of their own
making. Football programs are judged by their win/loss records with no asterisk
for money games. There is never a time when the NMSU football program should
sell a loss.
Selling football losses to support
high salaries castrates the program. All NMSU has gotten over the decades is
the need to sell even more losses. I have complained in my columns about this
for thirty years. I am told every time that I just don't understand. Yep, I
don't, even though I have a Ph.D. in Educational Administration.
NMSU’s primary goal should be to
fill the stadium for every home game. How do you do that? By playing teams NMSU
can beat. And becoming Bowl Eligible. This isn't Rocket Science.
Every year I am painfully aware of
the near-empty stadium toward the end of each season and sometimes from the
get-go. Each successive athletics department has reasons why filling the
stadium cannot be done. Year after year, decade after decade comes a long
litany of people who do not fill the stadium for every game.
Collegiate Football is part of the
institutional identity. Those who say NMSU can do without football are not
viewing students, town residents and alumni as consumers. The university must
have a viable football program. The Aggies must concentrate on playing teams they
can beat and break the Bowl Game curse.
NMSU needs to develop an effective
process of moving from mediocre to good to great. Teams like Boise State have
done that. Start smart and small. Build the program not by selling losses. Every
great team fills their stadium.
The always wait until next year NMSU football program
The movement to ban all air conditioning
Posted by
Michael Swickard
on Sunday, August 16, 2015
![]() |
| Passenger side air conditioning in 1953 for my aunt and uncle |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. For most of our country's history
what we wanted was fine if we worked for it and did not cheat anyone. But now
we are talking about changing the debate to: you should only have what you absolutely
need, not that other stuff you want.
Take money. the Socialists among us talk
constantly about the fact that people don't need as much money as they have.
This is especially so for those who have money left over at the end of the
month. Shouting about income inequality there is a move to take from the rich
and give to the poor until everyone, regardless of how hard they work, has the
same as everyone else.
But there is something worse. Money
is one thing, air conditioning is another. A headline caught my attention: New
York University Professor Wants Government To Stop Us From Using Air-Conditioning.
Gosh! And the professor thinks he has a good reason to get the government to
take all of our A/C units away from us.
Sociology professor Eric Klinenberg
wrote an op-ed in Time magazine entitled, Air-Conditioning Will Be The End Of Us.
He is concerned American's power use for air-conditioning will increase the
effect of Global Warming and of course Global Warming is just about to
extinguish the human race.
He is not alone. Several people I
have spoken with agree A/C is not needed by most people, it is only wanted.
Count me as wanting A/C in the New Mexico summers. Do I need it? No, but this
is America where I should be able to live as I desire, not as the Socialists
desire me to live.
I have lived in the heat quite a bit
of my life, some of the time with just shade and cool water as my only relief
from hot days. During the summers of my youth I lived on my grandfather's ranch
and there was no A/C. He said, "If you work in the sunlight, the shade
will be cool enough."
Back then all of our vehicles had
the open window air-conditioning: roll two windows down and drive. When I came
to college in 1968 I did not have a car so I walked to campus, about a mile
each way. I did so in the heat, cold and gloom of night. There wasn't rain and
snow because this was New Mexico.
Even when I got my first car all it
had was windows to lower the temperature. The truth is that most of us did not
have what is now considered a necessity, air-conditioning. I have lived in
houses without A/C and we just sweltered in the heat but survived.
So the Socialists among us are right,
A/C use in this nation is because we Americans want it. Socialists think they can
end this danger to the planet. The problem will be when the government decides
that not enough of us are voluntarily casting off this want and they mandate
the end of citizen owned air-conditioning. How will Americans take losing
something they really want?
I owned a weekly newspaper when
President Jimmy Carter was trying to push Americans to be hotter in the Summer,
colder in the Winter. My shop was visited by an inspector who marveled that it
was 60 degrees in the building so we were good Carter people.
Actually I didn't own the building
and it had no insulation so 60 was as warm as I could get it. Then the
inspector looked for our piece of paper that was supposed to be on the wall
saying we supported people being cold in the Winter.
I deadpanned, "We burnt
it." He was aghast and started filling out a replacement certificate. When
he handed it to me, I said to my print shop foreman, "Dame fuego" - give
me fire - so Pete threw me his lighter. I lit the certificate as the government
worker sputtered inarticulately. He never came back.
When the government takes all of our
A/C units away from us, I wonder if we sheep will continue to vote as we have
in the past. Or will there be a tidal wave of sweat sending different leaders
into office? Yep.
The movement to ban all air conditioning
Swickard: Getting swats at school
Posted by
Michael Swickard
on Sunday, August 9, 2015
![]() |
| Back row middle left - Kindergarten graduation, what a relief! |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D. This last week has been the start of
another public school year. I remember well my very first day in public school.
Quickly I was put in the corner for misbehavior. I thought I was sent to school
because they needed help running the joint. Not so.
They were alarmed that I said,
"Hey!" often to get their attention. "Wait your turn,
Michael," I was told. Within minutes I found that liquid doesn't flow up a
rope. The people at school didn't want help. Shuckins. The Ayatollah
Kindergarten decided drastic measures were needed. She called my parents.
They were relaxing at home and were
chagrined that they needed to come discipline me. I was glad to see them. I
explained that the place needed help running and that was what I was doing. I
noticed my parents were trying not to smile. They tried "The Kindergarten
knows better than you" but I wasn't having it.
Weekends were better since I didn't
have to deal with short-tempered school teachers. The worse part of it was I
was in an experiment where kids had to go to Kindergarten two years. It was a two
tough years of me putting up with those Michael-aversive people.
They thought the purpose of kindergarten
was to give them a job and to reign in boisterous boys. Every morning of those two
years my teachers took their bossy pills and thought I should do what they
commanded. I thought them wrong and we fought to a draw.
Then there were those public school years
afterwards. Along the way school leaders decided my brains were in the seat of
my pants and to get my attention they should give me swats. I do have to say I
never got an educational swat after high school.
It seems to me that the public
schools spent untold hours swatting me and it had no real effect upon me ever.
I always vowed to make no sign that they had hit me. So I refused to be intimidated
by the swat paddle which upset the sadistic teachers.
Mostly what they were able to do was
cause me to view school as a gang of thugs beating up small children. While the
swats have stopped in today's public schools, the thuggish behavior continues
with teachers being intentional mean to small children. It is considered rigor
but we know what evil lurks in some hearts.
I did get swatted the last week of
public school a few days before graduation. Two friends and I were making noise
in the hallway as we left the school. A teacher came out of her room to quiet
us. We blew raspberries and the assistant principal grabbed us. He said,
"Three swats or you do not walk at graduation."
I got four swats instead of three because
I said rudely to the poor man, "Knock yourself out Clyde, I don't care
what you do because in a couple days I'm outta here." Then I laughed at
him again but he had administered ten swats and was sweating profusely. He was
all stroked out and had to sit down. We laughed.
We made lots of racket leaving the
school and everyone ignored me. Fast forward eight years and I was teaching at
Albuquerque High School when some graduating seniors were making lots of noise
in the hallway. I stepped out and said, "Hey, glad you are still around. I
enjoyed all of you this year. Wherever you go I will always be your
friend."
One of the noisy kids started to
smart off to me but several others hushed him and the group walked over and
shook my hand and just said, "Thanks." And I have seen some of those
kids over the years. We always smile when we see each other. I never believed
in being a jerk to the students. Even if it got me fired I would never swat a
student. Not ever.
Too many adults in the public
schools carry big sticks and speak with loud voices. They judge and push the
students while students count the hours until they leave school forever. We
adults could do better if we were better human beings.
Email: drswickard@comcast.net
Swickard: Getting swats at school
Swickard: NMSU students becoming more quiet
Posted by
Michael Swickard
on Monday, August 3, 2015
![]() |
| Michael Swickard on NMSU Student Radio |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D.
"The
college that does not feel the need of a medium for the publication of its
various doings and saying must be a very quiet sort of place with students who
never play pranks and teachers who cannot appreciate a "break" when
it is made." In the first New Mexico State University yearbook, 1908
A student newspaper is a vibrant
alive burr under the saddle of the administration and focus of many conflicting
views. It breathes and snorts and fires the imagination. Or, it did in the
past.
Some of us who are former staffers
of the media at NMSU are saddened by this action. I was on my high school
newspaper and yearbook in Alamogordo as a photographer and when I came to NMSU
in the fall of 1968 I continued student photo journalism.
My father, a photography instructor
for the Air Force taught me well all phases of photography. My first year at
NMSU I worked with the Round-Up,
became the Head Photographer of the yearbook, worked on the student radio
station and got in on the ground floor of the television efforts.
I was even elected to the NMSU
Student Senate from the College of Arts and Sciences to protect the budgets of
the three media: the newspaper, yearbook and student radio station. Myself and
Brad Cates were the two real conservatives in the Senate. Brad was later elected
Student Body President.
In October of 1969 Harvey Jacobs, Journalism
and Mass Communications Department Head called me to his office. He almost
single-handedly built the NMSU media program and wanted me to do him a favor.
Justin Weddell, Class of 1908 was the
driving force in starting both the student newspaper and the yearbook. He was getting
a special honor for Homecoming and would be arriving from Chicago. Someone
needed to show him how the campus had changed. As someone who worked with the
student newspaper and yearbook, I was given the opportunity to spend the day
with Weddell.
As luck would have it, I respected
Harvey Jacobs and it was the very first thing he had ever asked me to do so I
was in for the day. Weddell was eighty-two and still in fairly good health. We
walked around with him saying, "Our student dorm, The Klondike was over
there until one night when it burnt down."
His Senior Thesis was The Art of the Southwestern Indian which
he mentioned. I asked if he had gone to see the pictographs at Three Rivers. He
had several times. I smiled and mentioned that my grandmother had taught school
in that one-room school in 1908. He did not remember her directly but
remembered the school.
We had a pleasant day and then it
was time for him to join other graduates for the Homecoming festivities. He
held my hand a few moments and said, "Don't let them kill what the class
of 1908 started." I promised to fight for the media. Already, even in 1969,
student newspapers and yearbooks were thought to be out of date.
The Round-Up essentially quitting the news business would not have surprised
Justin Weddell since students no longer read newspapers. They skim
electronically and stories over fifty words are in danger of being ignored.
I do not mourn for the Round-Up, I mourn for the learning
opportunity that the editors and news producers had in putting out the paper.
It came out twice a week in my era and once a week currently. That required writers
to be on deadline and editors to manage their time effectively.
Publishing once a month is like not
at all. The NMSU students have gotten quiet as they are surrounded by their
electronic world. I am not as old as Justin Weddell was when I spent a day with
him. Still, it was forty-six years ago and I'm no Spring Chicken. We are and
were Round-Up dinosaurs remembering a
better time.
Swickard: NMSU students becoming more quiet
Swickard: Good bomb or bad bomb?
Posted by
Michael Swickard
on Sunday, July 26, 2015
![]() |
| Enola Gay, the B-29 bomber is in in the Smithsonian |
© 2015 Michael Swickard, Ph.D.
In the 1939 movie, The Wizard of Oz, Dorothy was told by
Glinda, "The Munchkins want to know, are you a Good Witch or a Bad Witch."
Until then Dorothy and the viewing public had thought all witches were bad. But
The Wizard of Oz revolves around Good
Witches and Bad Witches.
That lesson might translate to other
things in our world. August 6th is the 70th anniversary of the atomic bomb over
Hiroshima, Japan. It followed the July 16, 1945 detonation of a 20 kiloton nuclear
device at Trinity Site, New Mexico, and was followed by the detonation of a
second atomic bomb over Nagasaki, Japan.
A few days later Japan
unconditionally surrendered. World War Two was over. It remains the most deadly
war of all time in our world. About three percent of the world's population
died in the conflict and that number might be low. In raw numbers the estimate
is sixty million people died.
And for the most part the dying was
over after two atomic bombs forced Japan to surrender. Especially in the last
thirty years there has been a fierce debate about those actions. Usually it is
an explosive argument when people discuss using two atomic bombs to end World
War Two.
Perhaps we should ask: were they a
good bomb or a bad bomb? Like witches we automatically assume all atomic bombs
to be bad. Were they, are they?
Certainly they have the liability of
injuring people with radiation long after the war has ended. But the official
position of our country and our politicians is that injury by radiation does
not matter at all. How do I know that? I am a Downwinder injured by the Trinity
explosion which injured thousands of other New Mexicans but our government and
politicians are still seventy years later ignoring our injuries.
The question most people ask: Did
the nuclear bombs really end World War Two? The day of surrender Emperor Hirohito
broadcast, "The enemy has begun to employ a new and most cruel bomb, the
power of which to do damage is, indeed, incalculable, taking the toll of many
innocent lives. Should we continue to fight, not only would it result in an
ultimate collapse and obliteration of the Japanese nation, but also it would
lead to the total extinction of human civilization."
It was very chaotic in Japan. Some members
of the Japanese Military did not want to surrender but they revered the
Emperor. Japan was in essence a dictatorship not of the Emperor but the
Military. The Emperor was truly a figurehead and General McArthur who ran Japan
in the first five years after the war's end understood this and allowed
Hirohito to have a post-war figurehead role.
For several years I lived in Japan
and heard several Japanese say that they had been ordered by the military to
sharpen broom handles and they were supposed to try to stab invading Americans
when they landed. They were grateful the war ended for whatever reason. They
did not wish to die needlessly.
Further, I drink coffee with a man
who was on a troop ship to Japan and was going to make the first of two major
landings. He says the reason he is still alive and had a career as a high
school teacher is that the war ended suddenly. He is a supporter of the use of
atomic weapons.
Seventy years later we can inspect
the plans that were in effect for the invasion to end the war. Operation
Olympic was to be on the Southern-most Japanese island of Kyushu November 1,
1945 while Operation Coronet the invasion of main island Honshu south of Tokyo
was scheduled for four months later.
The pentagon planning paper was called
Operation Downfall. It projected millions of deaths. But we and the Japanese
were spared that holocaust of death.
Can atomic bombs be good? Yes, when
they end a dictatorship and allow Japan to become a democracy. I told this to a
clerk in a store recently. She said she could not believe atomic bombs to be
good. I replied, the use of force, the use of good atomic bombs allows you to
reject the truth.
Swickard: Good bomb or bad bomb?







